Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Stumbling Blocks

Ok. This is a HUGE issue for some people in the Christian community. I honestly hadn't really thought anything much about it until recently. There was a furor years ago, it died down, only to be rekindled with the most recent and last movie in the Harry Potter series.

My kids like Harry Potter and so do I. I have read all of the books. My oldest two sons have read all of the books. My youngest son is just beginning to read the books. Here is something some people don't think about. They READ the books. They don't BELIEVE the books. Why did I read the books? To protect my children. I knew that they would be exposed in some way. The movies are on TV all the time. What happens if I leave them with a sitter who lets them watch it? Who is to blame when they have questions I can't answer? Me. At least with the way I have done it, I can CONTROL the situation.

I read the books so I could discuss them with my kids. We talked about how fiction and fantasy are different from the real world. We discussed how Christians don't use magic nor do we believe in magic. They also know that going to see a "magician" means sleight of hand and illusions. NOT casting spells and creating potions. They know that there are people who do those things and believe in it. They also know, without a doubt, that to do so is sin. We also discussed that there is no such thing as "white" magic or "good" magic. So, why would I deliberately expose them to this fantasy world? Because it is FANTASY. Plain and simple. It is adventure, it is interesting, it is exciting, and it is fun. I also am quite often liable to read anything that is causing controversy in order to be able to knowledgeably speak from either side of the issue.

I am hearing all kinds of things from people who disagree with this point of view. I am ok with people who disagree. If we all agreed on everything, life would be boring. However, what I am not ok with is people who take things out of context and try to impose their opinions on me and my beliefs. I will listen to anyone's side of an issue presented respectfully and in love. I will not be told that I didn't "find God right the first time so I need to try again" because I have read something I find amusing. I also disagree with people who do not verify their facts before running off at the mouth. I have seen comments such as "drinking blood is an abomination, a sin worthy of hell!" Ummm, does that even APPLY to unicorns? They are fictional, right?

Having said this, I must say, I would never want to be a stumbling block. We are admonished in Philippians 2:12 to "work out your salvation with fear and trembling" and in v.13 "For it is GOD who works in you to will and act in order to fulfill his good purpose." My salvation does not depend on someone else's convictions. My salvation depends on MY relationship with God. I HAVE worked this out. I know without a doubt that this issue does not affect my salvation nor my relationship with God, nor my children's. I Corinthians 8:9 says, " Be careful, however, that the exercise of your rights does not become a stumbling block to the weak." I have two perspectives on this.

The first one that sticks in my head is the way some Christians come across as, "I have all the answers, you are wrong, if you do this, you will go to hell." When you come at an individual, particularly a person who is not strong in such a manner, you can easily cause that person to turn away. By making someone feel as if the only way to God is to give up EVERYTHING that can be enjoyable causes people to not want to have a relationship with God. By the same token, if my watching Harry Potter (or Lord of the Rings, or Bewitched, or Chronicles of Narnia) causes a weak person to stumble, it is my duty to NOT talk about, watch, read, or embrace those things with that person. There again, we lead to working out our own salvations.

Do I expect everyone to agree with me? No. If you are offended or feel that these books, movies, stories are not for you. I am totally ok with that. I would never presume to tell a person that he or she HAD to agree with me because this is the way God and I see it. I would be willing to explain my point of view, however, many people will shut down and shut off their ears. Liking fantasy does not make me a bad person. It makes me different, even interesting to some. I will not apologize for being confident enough in who I am and in my relationship with God that I can and have seen and read something that is a pure work of fiction.

5 comments:

TaJuan said...

Shan,
Thanks for this prespective. I am a person who does not want to watch or read books that have magic etc. But it is my own personal conviction.
I say that to say, I have a daughter who loves the Twilight movies, which of course I was opposed to. And she totally went to a friends house to watch them ... cause she knew I would not let her. When I told her why I felt that way she told me she knew that it wasn't real and people are not vampires. She loves unicorns but knows they are fantasy also.
You helped me to see it thru her eyes and gave me a way to talk to her about it all. It helps me to see that she is not bound for hell because she watches such.
Thank you for your perspective. I will totally have to call you when it comes to what is in these movies and books ... as I still don't want to open myself up to the world of magic :).

Shannon Lumley said...

I totally respect your decision for yourself. I am glad you understand my point of view. I have also read the Twilight books. Once again, it was purely to see what all the hype was about. I loved them LOL! Thank you for being open-minded and willing to read this :)

Hope Carter said...

Shannon,
I completely agree with you. Both Timothy and I enenjoy HP and Twilight. We feel exactly the same way you do and we have even found aspects in HP that are almost an allegory for the passion story. I have read all the books for both movies and all the Narnia books. Why are these ant different than Snow White or Bedknobs and broomsticks? Both classic Disney movies. Which most Christians are ok with. Thanks for sharing. It is a refreshing view in the COG.

Shannon Lumley said...

Thanks, Hope! That has been one difficulty I have always had. Why are certain things ok and others not? If you are going to shun something, you should shun all. You can't compartmentalize and say one is ok over the other based on the production company. I appreciate your input!

Juawana Hall, O.D. said...

Excellent post. I love your blog. You have no idea how much I identify with SO MUCH you write. Its amazing how timely your notes are in my life :-)
All that said, I need some magic advice. My 4 year old is all the sudden talking about taking his (imaginary) magic wand and doing this and that. Turning our dog into a frog and stuff. I assume he got this from preschool.
I tell him we don't use magic and he doesn't get it. As a great mom, I thought I'd ask how you'd tell a 4 year old about why we don't use magic. The answer is easier if he were older, but I can't get him to "get it".
Thanks for your help!!